CJ Koome set to unveil Judiciary performance report despite court order
Crime and Justice
By
Nancy Gitonga
| Nov 20, 2026
A showdown looms in the corridors of justice following Chief Justice Martha Koome’s decision to push on with the launch of a report on judiciary performance.
Thursday, CJ Koome suffered a major setback in her plan to publicly expose the individual performance records of judges and magistrates after the High Court stopped the Judiciary from publishing the controversial data pending the hearing of a legal challenge.
However, the media has been invited to the launch on Friday. If the ceremony goes ahead as planned, it would be a case of a moral dilemma of the Chief Justice ignoring a court order but telling the public how judges and magistrates are performing their duties.
Justice David Mburu of Milimani High issued conservatory orders prohibiting the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) and the Chief Justice from publishing individual performance data for judges and judicial officers as an addendum, appendix or in any other form in the State of the Judiciary and Administration of Justice Report (SOJAR).
READ MORE
StanChart Kenya profit jumps to Sh10.5bn despite total income drop
NCA exposes gaps after 72 buildings collapse
NSE extends trading hours in push for global status
US beats China in race for Kenya's Sh8 trillion Mrima Hill rare earth mineral project
Why combining talent and technology is key to Kenya's development
US group wins Mrima Hill minerals contract
Certificate deals widen Kenya's seafarers access to global fleets
Half-truths: Ruto defends record but struggles to address the pain of cost of living
Kenya moves closer to naming its crude oil ahead of first oil production
Safety crisis deepens as building collapses claim 38 lives in 11 months
The dramatic intervention came barely hours after the Judiciary on Thursday morning published the report on the individual performance records on its social media platforms revealing the number of judgments, rulings and other determinations delivered by individual judges, magistrates, Kadhis and Small Claims Court adjudicators during the 2025/2026 financial year.
The orders now complicate Koome's unprecedented transparency initiative, which was intended to open up the performance of individual judicial officers to public scrutiny and strengthen accountability in the administration of justice.
In his directions issued on Thursday afternoon, Justice Mburu certified the application as urgent and ruled that the intended publication of the data, if allowed to proceed, could render the pending petition and application academic.
"Pending the hearing of this application interpartes, a conservatory order is hereby issued prohibiting the 1st and 2nd Respondents (JSC and CJ) from publishing individual performance data for Judges and Judicial officers as an addendum to, appendix to or in any other form, way or manner in the State of the Judiciary and the Administration of Justice Report (SOJAR)," the judge ordered.
Justice Mburu also directed the respondents and interested parties to file and serve their responses to the application within seven days.
The matter will return to court on December 1, 2026, for further directions.
The orders arose from a fresh application filed by Nairobi resident Duncan Kariuki, who wants the court to stop the publication of individual performance records until legal and policy safeguards are established.
Through lawyer Harun Muturi Njoroge, Kariuki argued that the planned disclosure raises fundamental constitutional questions touching on judicial independence, the privacy, dignity and security of judicial officers and the quality of justice delivered to Kenyans.
He contends that the Judiciary cannot introduce individual performance rankings without first establishing a clear legal, regulatory and policy framework governing how the information should be collected, assessed, verified and interpreted.
The petitioner further questioned the accuracy and reliability of the figures, arguing that the data had not been sufficiently verified and that some courts could be excluded from the publication, potentially resulting in discrimination among judicial officers.
In his supporting affidavit, Kariuki maintained that he was not opposed to transparency in the Judiciary but wanted proper modalities established to ensure the figures were presented fairly and in context.
He warned that publishing raw statistics without considering the different circumstances under which judicial officers operate could create an adverse impression of judges and magistrates.
"The petitioner is not opposed to the publication of the said data in principle but is only craving for formulation of the modalities of the publication for the data to have the basis for a sensible interpretation thereof," the affidavit states.
The petitioner also raised concerns that exposing individual performance records could subject judges and judicial officers to ridicule, cyber harassment and threats to their personal security and independence.
He argued that the publication could encourage a culture in which judicial officers are judged primarily by the number of decisions they deliver rather than the quality and depth of their legal reasoning.
Kariuki further questioned the respective constitutional and statutory powers of the Judicial Service Commission, the Chief Justice and the Chief Registrar of the Judiciary in determining how individual judicial performance should be assessed and made public.
Kariuki also cited the Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct on Judicial Well-being and provisions of the Constitution relating to judicial independence, equality, dignity and fair labour practices.
The court battle comes against the backdrop of growing debate within the Judiciary and the legal fraternity over the proposed publication of individual performance records.
On July 3, 2026, Koome announced that the Judiciary would begin publishing individual performance reports for judges and judicial officers from July 2026 as part of efforts to strengthen accountability and public confidence.
"As part of ongoing efforts to strengthen accountability, enhance transparency and deepen public confidence in the administration of justice, the Judiciary will begin publishing individual performance reports for judges and judicial officers from July 2026," she announced.
However, the initiative encountered resistance from the Kenya Magistrates and Judges Association (KMJA), which supported transparency but questioned whether the necessary groundwork had been completed.
KMJA President Justice Peter Mulwa said the association had requested that publication be properly sequenced because the Case Weighting Study was incomplete and there were outstanding gaps in the digitisation of the Judiciary's Case Tracking System.
The association maintained that publishing individual figures before addressing these challenges could result in unfair comparisons between judicial officers handling vastly different workloads and cases of varying complexity.
The Judiciary's report seen by The Standard, covers the period between July 1, 2025 and June 30, 2026, contains detailed schedules of individual judicial officers' output in four categories: judgments delivered, rulings closing cases, interlocutory rulings and other resolutions.